On 3/7 our class had a dilemma. Most of the class did poorly on the first exam including myself. The class had to come together, around 80 of us, and make a decision what to do about the grading of this exam and the format of the next exam. I thought that our class did an awesome job in coming together and collaborating given the size of the class and all of the ideas that everyone had for the first exam and the format of the second exam.
I remained relatively quiet and made a few comments to two women sitting next to me. Overall I personally handled the potential for chaos during the class decision making exercise by being the compromiser. The reason I chose these approach is being I believe that everyone in the class had a valid point in whatever they were concerned about. Collectively we all want to achieve the same goal: to somehow get a better result for our grades on the first exam and also, to change the format on future exams to have the opportunity to do well next time. Therefore, I was concerned with every personal idea in the class. Opposing ideas make for good discussion and lead to a better solution in the end and are built into the decision making process.
A leader evolved in the decision making process with some supporters as time pushed us all into desperation for resolve. The leader utilized more than one of the decision making approaches: She was the compromiser, the accommodator, and the collaborator. She was a compromiser because she worked as a mediator among extreme opinions exhibited by the "compete to win" sector of the class which I believe was a large amount of the class. Also, she used the accommodation approach by really hearing the concerns of others in the class and putting them before her own. She was also a collaborator by bargaining and negotiating. A good number of the class did not want an essay on the next test but she negotiated with the class by suggesting that the instructor would provide a choice of an essay topic. This suited the needs of the people who did not want the essay because it gave them option. I think that she did an excellent job. I was impressed.
I witnessed many in the class in the "compete to win" category. They stood by what the wanted and was almost impossible to convince otherwise. These were the most zealous group and the most difficult to bargain or negotiate with. It was these people that made the decision making process the most difficult because of their stubbornness. These people made the time limitations seem more suffocating because of their lack of compromise. I also witnessed some people as very quiet and avoiding the situation, or at least it seemed that way. I don't know what they were actually thinking. I was also relatively quiet but I was not avoiding the situation per say. I did express concern with certain topics.
I think that the leader handled the conflict exceptionally well. I think that by using a combination of decision making approaches gives the best results. The "Compete to Win" people made the process the most difficult. If I was the mediator I think that I would have handled the situation similarly if I didn't have a melt down and get frustrated with the "Compete to Win" fighters. I may lean more slightly to the Collaboration side if I was in charge of facilitating the process.
Overall, I thought this activity was awesome and energizing. I was really proud of our class and how we came up with a solution that everyone could live with.